Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pajtl 1372 days ago
Sure, but size is not what matters, density of population is. Of course nobody is expecting (equally good) public transport in all of Texas.
1 comments

You left out size of population, as well as the place having a size large enough to reasonably need transit. You can have 100 people packed in a single room and that is very dense, but if they are alone on a tiny room-sized planet then public transit won’t make sense. Neither will cars. To go anywhere they need to go straight to rockets. But that’s assuming there’s anywhere to go. Size of population and available places to go also matter.

Point is if you want to get hyper asperger’s about it, you can, but it’s not necessary to have done so because there is implicit information here, and besides, your final claim (density is what matters) ended up being incorrect, because holding you to the same standard that you hold others, you didn’t state all the implicit information.

Knowing that Singapore has a large enough population as we do know because it is well known as a large city-state, we can infer the density from that information combined with the small size. But density is not all that matters.