Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lolinder 1383 days ago
"Scale" has multiple meanings, and here I'm not talking about speed.

This interpreter is built around matching specific Regex patterns and then immediately executing hard-coded behaviors with a few slots for parameters. It's missing a whole lot of the skeletal structure that would be necessary to "scale" it up to support a generally useful subset of JS, much less the entire language. Without the necessary structure, it would be a buggy mess that's impossible to maintain, and you can't just take the existing code and structure it better: it's built on the wrong foundation. That's what I mean when I say it won't scale.

That's not a judgement against the team that wrote it! It meets their needs fine, and choosing a minimal solution is great engineering that takes a lot of guts in the current software culture. I like what they've done here. Just don't take it and try to scale it up into a full JS runtime.