Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cabbagesauce 1381 days ago
You're one of the anon-Bitwarden boys?

1) I want sane error messages on the client side.

2) I want my feedback on community forums not to be shushed. You screwed up — own it. Community mods aren't janitors to wipe out user feedback.

3) I want the extension to be working no matter what kind of server-side problems you have. Let me know about a sync problem but don't terminate my access.

But if you do think, that for $12 I get to be treated like an dog, too bad, there's enough options for me to take my business elsewhere.

3 comments

I can recommend Keeper (my current password manager of 2 years) or Passpack (previous password manager of 5 years). Never experienced any problems with either.

I am surprised that they are not more popular than "fan-favorites" like LastPass which I absolutely can't stand (it's like from the dark ages UX wise) or 1Password, or, for that matter, Bitwarden. Bitwarden particularly experience degradation of service like every month or so, maybe due to their popularity.

isn't keeper the one that sues people that disclose security vulnerabilities? I'd stay away as far as I can from that one.
Idk why you think you should be able to login to a cloud SaaS product while its down. From your comment here I highly highly doubt you were at all even remotely civil in that forum post $12 a month doesn't mean you get to be an asshole to people. Not all forms of Auth can be done locally, for example most 2fa requires server access.
I can feel uncalled hostility in your attitude, dictated by your conjecture which isn't the right indicator to make judgement about this specific incident. Ad hominem is irrelevant here since it's not about me but service operations.

Anyway, I'll still respond.

>Idk why you think you should be able to login to a cloud SaaS product while its down

The application works without internet access.

> Not all forms of Auth can be done locally, for example most 2fa requires server access.

TOTP validation can be done at the offline level. And the hardest proof of it is that the tokens themselves are generated offline. All that is required at the server side is shared secret and a Unix time syscall. This gets done at the browser extension level[0], no network required.

[0] https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/JavaScript/Refe...

Not even 12/m, it's per year!!
When you are on some corp firewall or mitm bitwarden has a very strange error message about owning keys or something. Took me a while to figure out the problem