Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by lemmiwinks 1379 days ago
So the only solution to climate change is anti-capitalism. Got it.
3 comments

Nah let's pump and dig every fucking last gram of resource on this planet and burn it to make our gadgets, we need more shit to buy and more shit to throw away, that will surely help. I heard the iphone 17 will solve climate change, coupled with the airpod 4 max S plus it might even cure cancer
Excellent conservative political answer, stand athwart history yelling No! (or something close to that).

Please engage in the conversation rather than trying to score internet points on a platform that is specifically trying to avoid such.

We aren't exactly overflowing with "solutions to climate change", and capitalism seems to be incentivising for further and further exploitation of the planet, rather than a reduction. Can capitalism support a degrowth economy?

Also I literally said

> where for "capitalism" if you don't agree with a totally Marxist analysis you can really substitute any structural issue that is causing us to not take anywhere near enough action on the climate.

If you don't agree that it's capitalism, choose your own systematic issue...

Capitalism and market economy is all about degrowth. It's a system that tries to make same amount of stuff using less and less resources. Because of it, we get constantly more efficient, and can support a higher standard of living using less resources. It's a system where the most efficient survive.

Resource over-use is caused by government intervention. It's the governments who try to pump up their GDPs with various policies, which causes ever-growing consumption and resource use. They literally control the interest rates to get everyone to consume as much as possible.

Only in a restricted economy. If you allow people to have children, then you get runaway consumption
Increase in efficiency allows population to grow without using more resources.

However, whether it grows is another question. Today, we are seeing a massive collapse in populations around the world, which is a huge problem and no one really knows the root cause.

I think that would be a good thing, if there were far less people
I think it's better to have more people, or at least keep the current level.