Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by treeman79 1383 days ago
Low density cities. Few places are like Chicago or New York.

The interstate highway system was actually for defense. Moving things from coast to coast was far to difficult.

FDR saw the German Highway system during the war and was rightfully jealous.

2 comments

Let's say you're right, and cities are low density. So what? What precludes them from having good public transit? Roads exist, why can't they be rail lines instead?

Roads are quite expensive, and there are many internet resources with tons of evidence and arguments about this: strong towns, not just bikes, climate town, etc.

Roads are much easier to interconnect than rails because road vehicles can make much sharper turns and handle steeper grades.

Point to point navigation has high utility and is difficult to acheive with rail.

Minimum viable roads are actually quite inexpensive: clear large vegetation from the path and there's a usable road. You can incrementally improve with path markers, grading, gravel, pavement, etc. Minimum viable rail is a much higher standard, which needs grading, railbed preparation, laying the rail, signalling and operations.

If only FDR had seen the Swiss system of streetcars…