[anoncept]

In my experience, typing dot requires a lot of quoting and brace-matching, often in editors without the best affordances for those operations, with so-so error reporting.

The result is that it’s very challenging to type syntactically correct dot at “line-speed”, e.g., if one is taking notes.

(This is one of several reasons that I think there is definitely still room for improvement in notation for graph-drawing, as I have begun exploring in my own work.)

[graphviz]

That's interesting. It's not hard to see the problem. HTML labels don't help, either. How do other languages solve this? Like, a shell HERE document that has one fixed string as a terminator? The graphviz lexer https://gitlab.com/graphviz/graphviz/-/blob/main/lib/cgraph/... seems hackable but disabling downstream processing of escapes elsewhere would be necessary too. Possibly this would mean bypassing some of the processing in the function make_label in https://gitlab.com/graphviz/graphviz/-/blob/main/lib/common/...

It's a disappointment or even failure of our current language scanning and parsing tools or, really, the way we used them, that this is not an easy exercise.

[anoncept]

One potential solution direction, which you can try out via my own incomplete drawing toy [1] is to treat punctuation characters like SP (“ “), COMMA (“,”), and SEMICOLON (“;”) as markers for the product operations of a family of monoids that allow you to specify more and more complicated sequences without requiring the typist to “move the cursor left” to add a matching character.

This way, simple lists can be specified via juxtaposition:

a b c

And then more complex lists

thing 1, thing 2, thing 3

and still more complex lists like

A complex thing; with data, and more data

can be specified in a way that is potentially still human-legible and easily editable.

Combined with ~instant feedback while typing and, ideally, a “brushing” system to allow selection of parts of the textual model via the linked drawing, I am hopeful that this can be solved resiliently, at least for the most common use cases.

(Part of why I am excited about OP’s work here though is that while I have done a fair bit in my own project on drawing a related kind of diagrams, I have myself only begun thinking about how to make the resulting drawings nicely stylable/themeable.)

[1] https://mstone.info/depict/ -> https://github.com/mstone/depict