Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by boris 1391 days ago
One thing that is unique about Estonia is its corporate tax system. Specifically, a business does not pay any tax on profit that it does not distribute as dividents. Meaning that any profit that you re-invest into the business (or just save for the rainy day) is not taxed. It's hard to appreciate what a game changer this is unless you've experienced the traditional system with capitalization of assets, depreciation, etc.

BTW, if anyone else knows of other countries with a similar tax system, please share (I did a bit of research but couldn't find any).

4 comments

The US has a similar system. It is not officially written into law, but any halfway decent tax accountant knows the loopholes.
I wonder if Biden's proposal to tax based on reported income to shareholders instead of taxable income, will change that for public companies: https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/what-bidens-minimum-b...
So Estonia wants to play the tax haven card like Malta and NL?

Ok, but let's not pretend that taking away tax money from other countries for stuff like healthcare and schools is something to be praised.

That really depends on how much more efficiently invested the money is in the startup vs in the government. Depending on which country you are in the answer is different but if you are in the first world the answer is almost certainly the money is better invested in the startup.
a business does not pay any tax on profit that it does not distribute as dividents

Can a business get around this by re-purchasing shares from the open market?

Yes, but how long can you do that? Also, our local stock exchange has listed only a few dozen companies.
As long as you want really. Say you have 100M shares outstanding. You do stock buy backs over the years now there is only 50M shares outstanding. You do a two way stock split, now there are 100M shares outstanding again.
You would still pay taxes when selling the stock for profit.
Yes, though in the US the capital gains tax (for investments held over a year) is quite often lower than the tax on dividends (which are treated as income).
As long as you want. When the share prices go up you do stock splits.
Private persons have to pay income tax when they sell their shares for a profit. So there is no way to avoid the income tax and getmoney out of the company without taxes.
But the stock buyback is at capital gains rates. And non-income personal revenue can have other advantages like avoiding various payroll taxes.
There is no such thing as "capital gains" tax, everything is covered by income tax, at the same rate. You can't use the US tax system to cheat Estonian taxes:)
How about a free zone in the UAE?