[underwater]

This is such a naive take. I assume you don't have kids or teens?

Children don't exist in a neat subservient bubble. They have peers, social pressures, see advertising, consume television and movies.

Our kid's school had everyone buy an iPad. Already, at pre-phone age, so much socialisation has moved into the digital space. FaceTime, iMessage, Roblox, etc.

I was going to say banning phones would be like a kid in the 80s without television. But really it would be like being a kid in the 80s who wasn't allowed to have a TV, listen to the radio, have a phone line, and wasn't allowed to socialise outside of school.

[sroussey]

Actually, TV was severely limited as were video games. We were told to go outside and not come back until it was getting dark.