[teej]

This "Slotted Counter" approach optimizes for a write-contention constraint, specifically row locks. From 10 seconds of Googling it seems InnoDB has other locks it uses on INSERT, I'd first check if moving the write contention to gap locks actually helps or not.

One side benefit of this approach is that getting the final aggregate is cheap, where compacting an append-only log table might not be.

[wcarss]

Thanks for taking the time to look into it, that's an interesting point. According to the manual [1], InnoDB's insert locking should not prevent other inserts from executing, it only takes an exclusive row lock on the inserted row. I agree that measuring would likely be smart.

This makes some intuitive sense, though: general purpose databases are expected to be _pretty good_ at handling the case of "add new data" with no other specific conditions, e.g. on other rows or tables' existing data.

I also agree with your last point. Running count() all day on this wouldn't be great, and compaction would take real time. I assumed that most high throughput write scenarios for something like an event count or view count can be a few minutes (or hours, or days) out of date, at which point read caching would be my first stop before clever summation algorithms, which are still pretty cool.

1 - https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/8.0/en/insert.html