Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Melting_Harps 1432 days ago
> DALL-E and GPT-3 are the polyester of design and creative construction. They're cheap; aesthetically uncomfortable. We'll turn to humans for high-quality design until we actually get AGI, and those systems are not a path to AGI.

I wish this were true, because it assumes a lot about Humanity living up to it's highest potential in terms of QC; but the truth is we're talking about digial content creation, which has been churning obscene amounts of data on a daily basis in the Internet era. And this means that it isn't about 'the best of the best' what it actually is a race to the bottom in terms of 'good enough' source material which is as disposable and fleeting as it's consumers attention span.

As a space nerd (its in my bio) I followed James Webb since Cassini was decommissioned/crashed and I found out about the necessary crypgenic tests to make Jw work were underway, but even as impressive as I find the images we see (and they are breath taking) I'm still spending way more time on DALLE-2 subreddit admiring all the prompts because I still don't have access to it myself and like the sheer novelty of it all.

You want a more closer analogue than polyester clothes? Try food: processed junk and by extension the American diet has made us awash in excess and rather than create more discerning consumers who have all the options that Modern chemistry, biology and AG science have to offer to shift the market to a more sustainable and higher quality point: we instead face the stark reality that the 1-2 killers in most developed countries are heart disease and diabetes that are directly correlated to the over consumption of cheap junk. Obesity remains one of the biggest threats to over all quality and longevity of an individual's life!

I study AI and ML and I have many artists friends, I used to be a cook so it's not a far leap, and we often discuss that this is inevitable: the inability to excel and to standout in a World in just one medium due to the advancement of technology.

It's not enough to be a creative who just focuses on music or painting, or sculpture if you want to have anything but a self-funded gallery where you try to sell your pieces to the attendees (often at a loss) in order to market yourself in the hopes of a larger commission that lets you quit your day job (or at least have a hiatus) when social media has availed itself as a gallery of what may not be the best artists in the World but the most prolific and often those with the best marketing and most followers to stay as the top trending in your discipline.

It's something we did encountered sooner in the culinary World as food porn became as ubiquitous as it was pre-covid so I see it quite clearly, it wasn't enough to deliver amazing service and provide a good meal sourced from artisans and local farmers and grow from word to mouth, now you had to play the social media game and become influencers or host influencers and then have them 'engage' with their demographic to expand your clientele and reservations for that quarterly push: and as was our case it helps if you are related to a certain tech mogul who dominates social media and try to ride coat tails where ever possible. And even that isn't enough as you still have to pay off yelp for keeping bad reviews at bay in a perverse game, while gamifying Google reviews etc... but we had tech giants buy-out on a weekly basis, proving it works.

It's becoming such that it's less about the execution of the art or the craft itself but rather doing N amount of things to remain as a signal amongst all the noise while the art becomes a secondary possibly tertiary part of what keeps the lights on; techies wanted disruption, and this is what it looks like in the 21st century.

I think this may be required reading for kids just graduating HS and thinking about what to do, as it gives a sobering view of what has happened in just a short duration when it comes to AI in certain, often precarious, Industries [0] and how it can potentially shape culture itself as so much of AI growth is in the surveillance-economy.

0: https://www.technologyreview.com/supertopic/ai-colonialism-s...