Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hubraumhugo 1435 days ago
You won't get a response from them. A famous list revealed that almost all top subreddits are moderated by the same people: https://www.reddit.com/r/ThatsInsane/comments/pbloje/almost_...
3 comments

I control a single fairly inactive subreddit with the name of my hometown (please don't go look for it!) I don't pay a lot of attention to it, but I'm around to perform whatever moderation is necessary.

A couple of years ago someone contacted me in private, suggesting I might want to hand over the subreddit to them so they can "improve it". Looking into the user, they were a powermod already controlling a dozen other subreddits. They posted aggressively to all of them, often the same thing to multiple of these subreddits. There was a whole bunch of crypto promotion. I said okay, I'm willing to hand over the reins to someone better, but anyone can submit to a subreddit; you might at the very least want to actually become an active participant in the community first so I can see if you're serious; I can even make you a moderator to begin with.

Their response (paraphrased)? "This requires too much time and dedication for me to do it experimentally, without any guarantees that afterwards I won't be kicked out. Have a good life."

I think there's a major difference in perspective between powermods and, you know, regular subreddit mods. To me, a subreddit belongs to its community - which means whoever shows up to engage with it. It's a convenient structure for organizing content submitted by people with a shared interest. My job as a moderator is to keep it clean of content that infringes platform rules and to enforce the will of the community in ways that the voting system isn't suited for. This can mean doing very little, if the subreddit is small. But a powermod like this one seems to require absolute control. Subreddits must be "theirs", their project, before they will engage, and they see it as their responsability to "grow it", to actually provide the content if necessary. They think a lot about karma and metrics and partnerships. They seem to me like control freaks who really, really need more hobbies (no offense, guy from back then).

I retain my lone subreddit to this date not because I am in any way well suited to do so, but to protect it from being nabbed by people like this. I'm always mildly worried the powers that be will think I'm squatting, but I'm an active redditor in general and I'm happy to keep an eye on contributions - which can be made by anyone. Maybe one day a community member will show up who is truly passionate about the town and suited to take my place and do more... css stuff with it.

I bet those very same people, without awareness of the irony, promote the outrage about concentration of wealth or income inequality.
ah, there's a way to wealth by being a subreddit janny?

edit: I vouched the reply comment, don't know why it got flagged.

https://imgur.com/a/0UOVV7q

"I deserve this position, it's the natural order of things, how dare you suggest this privilege was achieve through any means but above-board."

Edit: What the heck? I just explained the parallel, in response to a low-effort, uncurious comment that totally missed it, and I'm flagged? Sheesh.

Edit2: Thank you.

I tell all of the biggest whiners all of the time, I'd be more than happy to give mod permissions to (almost) anyone who asks and expresses interest.

The only thing I'm gaining by volunteering to steer conversations on a subreddit is the loss of my free time.

I wasn't able to reply to your comment when it was flagged. bad moderation strikes again!

this is pretty funny.