Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gernb 1439 days ago
I know this will get downvoted into oblivion and I'm not defending Microsoft, but....

I'm symapthic to your plight but you named your product based on 2 common nouns. It'd be like someone making a restaurant called "hamburger" and the complaining that others are confusing people because they sell "hamburger".

If you're starting a new project/product and don't not want to end up here you should probably pick a more unique name. Examples. Python, not 'scripting-lang', "Firefox" not "browser" or "web-browser", "gIMP" not "Image-editor", "mongodb" not "database" etc...

And I know someone is going to nitpick that "Python" is just a noun but in context it's got nothing to do with languages, computing, etc. so it works as not directly describing the product in ways that others are likely to use when the come out with a similar product.
1 comments
kylecarbs 1439 days ago
Kinda like how Microsoft took "code"?
link
DistractionRect 1439 days ago
Their cli commands generic, but their product name has always been distinct. It has always been Visual Studio Code and now Visual Studio Code Server. VS Code, VS code server for short.

Your branding, "coder" and "code-server", is just super generic and popular terms. That's what makes it hard to search for, not the cli command names.

link
jen20 1438 days ago
> It has always been Visual Studio Code

Perhaps since public release, but I was informed by a PM who was part of the original product development that this was a concession to marketing, and it did not always have the name “visual studio” attached.

link
isitmadeofglass 1438 days ago
Which is exactly OPs point. If they’d brought it forth with just the name “code” it would have been just as dumb as these guys complaining about code-server. Which is exactly why it ended up vscode, which is destiny enough that it possible both to market, distinguish and protect as a brand.
link
alephnullshabba 1437 days ago
Worth mentioning that gitpod's openvscode-server is a third option. I prefer it to code-server since gitpod's has proper parity with a desktop vscode install, while coder's implementation fails to work with several plugins when loading them in manually
link