Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bluehatbrit 1453 days ago
I think Slack has a place in communication but it has a really poor balance. It's so easy to create and send a message to a channel and tag a few people. As a result it moves quickly and makes it hard to digest and reply slowly. It's also extremely hard to find things again later, even with the improvements to search.

Back in the days of IRC a lot of people thought lack of history was a "missing feature" but now we have it with Slack I think it was probably the best feature of IRC. When the platform has no memory you're often pushed away from it for anything that's deeper. No one can come along later and find your messages so you know you can't put anything that requires wide visibility or input there.

I'm not going to shill for IRC and say everyone should go back to it or anything, it's not really practical. But that said, I do think Slack has a huge flaw in it's design of making it so easy to send messages and pretend everyone's going to see it.