[infogulch]

Interesting theory for a specific mechanism: "local temperature difference-induced convective cooling". Could be falsified by giving both initially-hot and initially-cold samples a stir rod, expecting the cooling performance of the initially-cold sample to improve to match the initially-hot sample.

[waterhouse]

Ho ho, guess what?

> The Scottish scientist Joseph Black investigated a special case of this phenomenon comparing previously-boiled with unboiled water; the previously-boiled water froze more quickly. Evaporation was controlled for. He discussed the influence of stirring on the results of the experiment, noting that stirring the unboiled water led to it freezing at the same time as the previously-boiled water, and also noted that stirring the very-cold unboiled water led to immediate freezing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mpemba_effect

I'm surprised the article didn't mention this.

[infogulch]

Wow! I guess that's the final answer then. Maybe to seal it, devise the inverse experiment where you somehow inhibit normal convection in boiled water and expect to see it take as long as the cold water.

Very interesting!