Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pueblito 1461 days ago
No, with copyright law you get ownership, the nft is just a public receipt
2 comments
ceejayoz 1461 days ago
The copyright holder is free to write up a license that says the current holder of the NFT may use it as if they hold the copyright, though. Many NFTs don’t, but it’s possible.
link
knorker 1461 days ago
But nothing guarantees that the seller of the NFT, the current holder of the NFT, is also the current copyright holder.

It's basically completely disconnected, so while the transfers may traditionally be done at the same time between the same entities, that's not a contract. The NFT just gives you a Blockchain url. If you didn't sign anything else then you got nothing else.

link
ceejayoz 1460 days ago
In the case of BAYC specifically, though, the contract guarantees that.

https://boredapeyachtclub.com/#/terms

> When you purchase an NFT, you own the underlying Bored Ape, the Art, completely.

> Subject to your continued compliance with these Terms, Yuga Labs LLC grants you an unlimited, worldwide license to use, copy, and display the purchased Art for the purpose of creating derivative works based upon the Art (“Commercial Use”).

link
knorker 1460 days ago
> you own the underlying Bored Ape, the Art, completely.

No, you just have a license to use it according to a license. That's very clearly "not owning".

It's something, but it's not owning.

link
ceejayoz 1460 days ago
Did you miss the first part? The original copyright owner is explicitly saying in their terms that you get ownership.

You’re just restricted by contract to pass on said ownership if you sell.

It’s like a house with a homeowners association. Can’t ditch the HOA by selling. Still own the house.

link
knorker 1460 days ago
This is all legal theatre to distract from the fact that there is no ownership change. Which is what I said.

You yourself said that all you get is a license, not ownership.

That is not even remotely close to the legal basis under which HOAs have power, which is a lien on the house, not with you.

House: You bought a house with an HOA lien.

NFT: You licensed (do not own) an image. Like YOU quoted there is no ownership change at any point.

These are not even remotely similar.

link
cratermoon 1461 days ago
Remember the case of the crypto guys who bought a physical copy of Dune worth $40,000 for $3 million and thought that gave them the rights to make an animated series out of it? Good times. https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/books/a38815538/dune-c...
link