Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by bejelentkezni 1463 days ago
The article basically says that you have to read the Bible to understand why you think the way you do about anything because you live in a country with a history of having a majority-Christian population. I disagree. Most people's ethical frameworks are very simple and are usually just least-harm principles with a little window dressing. And insofar as they aren't, they are usually not particularly compatible with secular society. For my part I don't see the need to give special attention to a particular ethical text just because so many other people have for so long.
1 comments

I think you're diluting their content a bit, but I largely agree. Their thesis read (to me) like they're insisting that the Bible is relevant because it framed a lot of the choices we made in the past: that much is true, and fairly relevant. But whether or not the parables of the Bible have relevance to modern society is a completely different discussion, and one that I feel like this article is (perhaps unfairly) baiting people into.

It's definitely a secular fluff-piece, but I don't think the thesis is that outrageous.