Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by CrazyStat 1462 days ago
> In the presence of outliers the median is a better predictor of underlying long-teem trends.

Not if outliers are REALLY FUCKING IMPORTANT, like, say, extreme weather events.

2 comments

Outliers are likely to drag the averages down, not up. The only really substantial global outlier events are volcanic eruptions, which cause a net cooling. Everything else (hurricanes and the like) is just heat moving around
We're looking at individual airport temperature records here, not global means.
So? A big volcanic eruption could cool many airports.
Once we recognize that we're talking about local rather than global there are many local outliers that increase temperatures, countering your argument that volcanic eruptions are the only global outliers.
Extreme weather events are a symptom of global warming, not a cause.
Yes and?
And that means their measurement contributes to the noise when attempting to identify the long-term causal trend. Taking the median is the correct step. One doesn’t measure the output and assume it’s the input.