Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by mjburgess 1466 days ago
I sincerely have had no reply to any of these points.

Either bitcoin is a deflationary currency, in which case it repeats the servre financial crises of the 19th C. and early 20th C. in which an economy is imprisoned into a rate of inflation set by blind non-economic forces. In which, as an economy, is horrifying: consumer protection is impossible by design, the owners are the controllers (feudalism), it's entirely public (so you're entire economic life is available to be profiled by used by others), etc.

Or its an asset. If it's an asset its a ponzi scheme.

It's clearly mostly being held as an asset, and traded as an asset by criminals and dictators because it has some ponzi-value. This ponzi-value will disappear as soon as anyone actually tries to use this as a serious currency, as with someone planting a tulip bulb for the flowers... no one wants tulip flowers (lol).

No one wants an incredibly deflationary economic system, controlled by the holders of coins, forked on behalf of the landed gentry, with one's private economic history plastered across the whole internet, with incredibly slow transactions, with immutable histories, and so on.

As soon as anyone actually "plants the tulip bulb" crypto is, quite seriously, f*ked. No one wants tulips. If I were holding crypto the last thing I'd do is actually try to get any one to take is seriously as a currency.

The number of delusional far-right libertarians who dream of being feudal lords is the c.5% of young angry men it's always been. And likewise, if they ever achieved anything, the state would put a stop to that immediately. No one wants your tulips. But i'd just love to see you plant them!

Go, run something on bitcoin, you'd wipe crypto off the map over night.