Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by JoshCole 1477 days ago
> We can agree that "the entire structure is wrong" because the "entire structure" is giving a wrong formula for the EV and saying "this is the formula for the EV."

We aren't in agreement about this. I realize we have to fix this, but fixing it doesn't resolve the paradox. It is a red herring.

> Yes, switching and not switching have the same EV and you can always switch.

With all due respect, this isn't true and asserting this doesn't resolve the paradox. See my other reply for why it doesn't resolve the paradox.