Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by degusta 5350 days ago
You might be right re it gets better - though not as sure about the ICS bit. It is my intention to keep at it & add (ideally) every phone.
1 comments

Here, I'll fill in a data point you missed:

Motorola Milestone XT720 released June 2011 (USA: August)

Runs 2.1

No bugfixes

No updates

No upgrades

Buggy as hell. 2.2 upgrades and flash support pledged by Motorola sales/support at the time of release in the US -- later clarified that those employees had been "confused" when the mothballing was made official in late November.

Those Apple green bars look quite nice, but I'm not a fan. Maybe add some Windows phone.

The problem as I see it is that since Android is Open Source, the manufacturers don't abstract their innovations into a HAL. For example, Motorola's FM radio and HDMI support is peppered all over inside the core eclair framework. So, someone has to mix it all together again with each new release. Usually in the FOSS space, we like to believe that the effort of maintaining private forks encourages companies to contribute their efforts back to the open source project. That doesn't work here, because manufacturers like Motorola also have the viable option to simply abandon their forks. Which is even less effort.

Apple has a huge economy of scale--only four or five devices (most very similar) with relatively humongous market share per device. The personnel/device ratio obviously supports a much better customer experience than any Android device can offer (with the exception of perhaps the Android developer phones).

I can only assume Microsoft knows what they are doing and enforces abstractions and barriers that limit the scope of manufacture monkeying.

This phone was released in 2010, not 2011, right?
Yup, sorry, don't know why I typed that.