Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tvararu 1482 days ago
I personally find it to be true.

Apple Music has a feature based on iTunes Match that will take your local files and attempt to match them based on their metadata and audio fingerprint.

The last time I used it, from my (then) ~5000 song library, it matched ~3600. That means that a good third of the music I listen to is not available in the same exact version on streaming services.

I dug into why, and reasons include:

- The LPs were never licensed properly. Such as Exmilitary by Death Grips, which is a bootleg release with copyright issues.

- The artist hasn't signed up for streaming, like it used to be the case with Tool. Or they only stream on one platform and not another. Dr. Dre and Jay-Z come to mind. All three artists I mentioned in this bullet are "really mainstream."

- The version I like is not the streaming release. I like the casette version of Ashes 2 Ashes, Dust 2 Dust by Tommy Wright III, but not the CD reissue.

- The artist is actually too niche. I have quite a few things in my collection from Bandcamp or Soundcloud that don't exist elsewhere.

- The release is "weird." Like the radio stations from the classic GTA games.

1 comments

Also, Apple Music allows you to just put any music in there and sync across devices, if you're missing something.

The reason between Apple Music and iTunes Match is that the latter doesn't replace your existing copies with the alternatives it find in its database. AM will gladly do it unless what you have offline is truly unique.