Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by outworlder 1482 days ago
That's... appalling. My 2019 Leaf has absolutely zero problems maintaining distance with adaptive cruise control, using the ancient technology formerly known as radar. It can somehow even see stationary vehicles, something I thought wasn't feasible.
3 comments

>It can somehow even see stationary vehicles, something I thought wasn't feasible.

Radar seeing stationary objects is trivial, it sees them just like it sees any other. The trick is seeing only the stationary objects which are actually relevant; e.g. not seeing a street sign suspended above the road, or a tree next to the road, but only the stationary objects in the path of the car. The radar configuration that Tesla use[s/d] apparently has awful angular resolution, making this differentiation difficult if not impossible. But this isn't inherent to all radar technology; some radars can have good angular resolution. For instance with SAR or ISAR, you can produce high resolution 2d images. But I don't know what kind of radar systems your Leaf has.

Doesn't it also have to handle things like windy roads and steep angle changes when going uphill? it seems you need both vision and radar to confirm things, eg:

- when on level ground approaching a steep hill, the radar might not know if the object directly in front of the car is just a continuation of the road or not

- when approaching a sharp curve in the road, is the object directly in front of the car actually in its path, or is it just on the side of the road

Are you sure about stationary? My 2018 leaf does not do that. I replaced the system with Open Pilot and never looked back. I also have a Tesla Model Y sometimes for testing. It is amazing how much better OpenPilot is. On the highway it is unbeatable and also able to recognize stationary objects like cars and motorbikes.
Yeah, never had a problem with my Hyundai as well. It also does lane keep assist perfectly on the highway using just the front cameras.
My Hyundai doesn’t seem to recognize stationary objects though. Also, the seconds after a car has merged into my lane in front of me are scary - my car doesn’t immediately recognize the new situation.