Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by PaulDavisThe1st 1482 days ago
> on the whole I've had much fewer issues with eTap than I had with mechanical Ultegra.

Which might say more about Ultegra than the overall question of cable-driven vs. electronic shifting.

1 comments

It absolutely does.

It says that cable-pull systems require more (and more intense) maintenance than electronic systems do.

I dunno. Maybe this is true for off-road bikes, but I have basically never done any maintainance on my (numerous) cable-pull systems after they get through the cable stretch phase.
All of mine are road.

My old 9-speed bike is rock solid, but I ride it rarely (utility purposes, basically).

My 11-speed mechanical bike needed adjustment probably 3-4 times a year (and on one of those occasions it'd be time to swap out the cables). Until I upgraded the shifters would eventually "eat" cables (well, on the right side anyway) and strand me in the lowest cog (Ultegra 6800), which was a huge hassle.

My 11-speed eTap bike asks only that I charge the batteries periodically. In the 2 years I've had eTap on that bike, I've spent MUCH less time futzing with the drivetrain than I did when it was mechanical Red, or than I did when I rode the Ultegra bike full time.