Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by whiplash451 1521 days ago
Interesting. How is this implementable realistically, though? Asking genuinely.
2 comments

1. Place a moratorium on any new water rights. (So no starting new farms with new claims, etc)

2. Identify all existing water rights holders. Every single farm/lot with some kind of water privileges. I'm sure there are thousands.

3. Determine how much water they used over, say, the last 5 years. This is obviously the hardest part, but it's no harder than many other large government projects. You'd probably have to use some estimation, formulas, etc - and it won't be perfect. It would take a couple of years and there would be a lot of wrangling. Similar maybe to housing assessment values. Probably include an appeal process as well, just like you can appeal a house assessment.

4. Give each user a new numerical water cap (say, 500k acre-feet), that is 125% or so of above usage. This will avoid hurting existing farms by allowing them to continue using water as they have been, with even some room for growth - but still puts a fence around the problem.

5. Require metering of all ag water, with random audits for enforcement and stiff penalties for violations.

6. Use the state's very large budget surplus to buy up those numerical water rights from the lowest bidders until the water crisis goes away.

1-5 already describes the legal process in California that has been used for the last 40 years to adjudicate water conflicts.

Number 6 is the sticking point and why we see so much gnashing of teeth.

really simple. If a city wants more water it writes a big check and buys it from someone who has it.