Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by anfractuosity 1485 days ago
Out of interest, would you get a similar bandwidth using DDRx on this card over PCIe, to using DDRx in the standard memory sockets on a motherboard

Edit: Looks like the slowest DDR4 gives 19200 MB/s https://uk.crucial.com/support/memory-speeds-compatability

Not sure what PCIe that card supports is though

2 comments

Looks like the card is PCIe 4.0 x4, which gives about 8GB/s. Not sure if this board is driving the RAM at full speed, or how many controllers there are, but more lanes could make this faster.
Looks like one controller per lane, so if this 4x card finds a good market we might be looking at 8x or 16x siblings in the future.

This isn't a good device for most home users, but for businesses that cache a lot of high speed data this could be a useful tool.

I haven't kept up with the speed and feeds, but in general PCI bandwidth is a decimal order of magnitude less than all the memory controller bandwidth
A modern AMD Zen3 has more PCIe bandwidth than DDR4. With somewhat slow ram even if you measure half-duplex.