Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by guerrilla 1489 days ago
Ohhhhh you must mean that military defeated by the Taliban using AK-47s, RPGs and tacticals, right? The same one defeated by the Viet Cong? Your argument is trash.

How's Saudi Arabia doing against those shoeless Houthis (i.e. 8 years later)?

1 comments

lol.

From a sister comment:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democide > Democide is the murder of any person or people by their government, including genocide, politicide, and mass murder.

Your examples are NOT US Military trying to kill citizens. And Viet Cong? Really? You are grasping, how about you throw in Civil war references too.

The point is technology has changed the battlefield. Personal firearms mean little - not nothing, but little - on a battlefield with tanks, drones, air superiority that the US has sooo much of compared to any other modern military, including Saudi Arabia.

How is Saudi Arabia doing? I don't know. How about you visit the region, do the tourist thing in complete safety while you might see in the media that the Houthis even exist. I think they're doing fine. Not that I agree with their approach...

But back to the Democide point: If the US Military went insane and wanted to eradicate every other US citizen then they could do so easily.

But the US Military wouldn't. Because a military is made up of humans, with a heart and a conscience and killing their own families and children is not even a thought to contemplate. While "pry my guns from my dead hands" types are happy to continue the status quo...

> Personal firearms mean little - not nothing, but little - on a battlefield with tanks, drones, air superiority that the US has sooo much of compared to any other modern military, including Saudi Arabia.

Nope, this is nonsense abd exactly the point that the examples refute. A poorly equipped army can defeat the US military.

A poorly equipped army might in an environment where the US military has to be picky about who it shoots.

"Democide" is not that.

> to be picky about who it shoots.

Like Vietnam and Afghanistan, right? Please stop.

If you want to live in a fantasy world where you can take on the US military, feel free. It won't come to pass anyway.