Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ukj 1484 days ago
Yes it is a liberal arts degree: no humans - no need for computation. Understanding ourselves and our needs is necessary for inventing; improving or sustaining any technology.

Yes it is a STEM degree: no rigor - no computation. Understanding how the universe works is necessary in order to exploit matter and convince it to do computations for us.

Everything humans do (STEM included) is for humans; and by humans.

This bipartisan view of universities and faux-conflict isn’t useful.

2 comments

> no humans - no need for computation.

I would disagree with this statement. I have a pet AI program which can get some work done and gain some cryptocurrencies for that and pay for its hosting for keep doing that work. I am sure the AI will overlive all the humans and it really needs some computations for living.

I disagree with your disagreement.

Why do humans need/invent computation, hosting, cryptocurrencies and AI?

I can’t fathom any data center remaining online for more than a few weeks/months if all humans keeping it running magically disappeared.

> Why do humans need/invent computation, hosting, cryptocurrencies and AI?

Because they use to have some spare time?

> I can’t fathom any data center remaining online for more than a few weeks/months if all humans keeping it running magically disappeared.

That few weeks my pet AI will be refusing your statement that no human means no need for computations.

Then step aside and take a vow of silence.

Let me speak with your AI. Let it refute me by telling me about it’s needs.

Queue excuses…

Science, tech, and math fall under liberal arts. You’re creating a distinction where there isn’t one.