Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by automatic6131 1492 days ago
>Maybe body builders lose lean body mass when they fast Well, highly fit people certainly lose lean body mass when they fast, which you're probably not (even if you're fairly fit)

And bodybuilders DON'T lose fat when they fast because they take supraphysiological doses of hormones (steroids) that prevent the body losing muscle - and usually eat protein throughout their fast too. So not a good example.

1 comments

> eat protein throughout their fast too

Aren't these contradictory? If you eat (protein or otherwise) you're not fasting.

I think they misspoke and what they meant to say was that bodybuilders use a zero/low carb diet, in which case their statement holds true.
Their whole argument was around body builders not losing fat when fasting, so if you're right, this is just irrelevant. No one expects people to lose fat when they're not caloric restricted.