Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jvanderbot 1500 days ago
> Code is law in crypto

The courts have not really tested that, have they? I figure HN would alert me if they had.

A wounded party will claim an exploit. Most bugs / security flaws are, in fact, code that is working perfectly as written, but not as intended.

1 comments

This is like saying a word doesn't exist because it's not in a dictionary.

Dictionaries reflect the public's usage of words, not the other way around.

Similarly, courts are supposed to reflect the values of people, people's values aren't informed by the courts.

Fine, but my values say that fraud is fraud whether you do it on a blockchain or not. I expect most of the public to agree and the laws of most countries to eventually reflect that even if some crypto maximalists don't like it.
I don't follow the analogy, but here's one that works for me: it's like leaving your door unlocked by accident, b/c you didn't understand the lock properly or were in a hurry. Negligence, sure, but it takes a person exploiting that negligence to get to the point of theft.