Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hayyyyydos 1505 days ago
I'm really not a fan of sites that pop up "Log in with Google" with your account details prefilled. It's creepy.
4 comments

I don't like it either. You can thankfully turn it off in your Google settings.

https://www.howtogeek.com/735152/how-to-turn-off-the-sign-in...

Thank you! I try my hardest not to use Google for anything besides Gmail and YouTube and that popup always infuriated me. Had no idea you could turn it off.
It's Google who knows your data, not the site.
I completely understand that - but it's still creepy, and it's a reminder of how big tech follows you around the internet. As soon as I see it, I choose to leave the website.
I did not experience any such thing when clicking on this link. I use FF and Ubuntu, but I do have a Google account that is linked to plenty of other stuff.
your browser or password manager is pre-filling the details, not the site.
No, this is Google providing authentication with your Google account to third-party websites. If you are already logged into a Google account, it suggests that you log in with that account with a popup saying "Continue as <your name>" and shows your email and avatar.

It's an iframe so the website itself doesn't have access to your data, but this is not obvious just from looking at it - it looks like part of the site. To me it feels like it teaches users to trust websites in ways that make them susceptible to phishing.

Yeah, that’s why I dislike it as well. Imagine the same “sign in with google popup” but it’s just a floated div on the page. A user who uses the “continue as button” might be comfortable typing their password in there, thinking it’s part of the browser
Ah, I didn't know that it's an iframe and I'm always a bit creeped out by it (it really isn't obvious!). Thanks!