Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by version_five 1492 days ago
Bitcoin is very smart. When I first learned about it, I thought it was so cool how it all came together, the combination of cryptographic security, distributed trust, even a Forth-like mini language built in. I made my own coin, I played with the source code, I made my own nonstandard protocol that used a bitcoin blockchain (unfortunately I never bought any bitcoin, but at any given time it's a terrible investment, even if it's paid off retrospectively).

Anyway, I say all this because I really find it clever, and I really wanted it to be able to do something useful, but the reality is, it doesn't. It's never going to be useful, it's been adopted by scammers and mountebanks, it has no utility and will cause so much harms in the scams that it supports.

So while it seems like a cool innovation, and from a purely technological standpoint it is, in reality it's poison. In that regard, it has (sorry for the tired analogy) a lot in common with communism. Cool idea, doesn't work at all, destroys lives. We need to let it go.

2 comments

>"When I first learned about it, I thought it was so cool how it all came together, the combination of cryptographic security, distributed trust, even a Forth-like mini language built in."

Interesting, could you elaborate on the Forth bit? Where does this fit in? This is the first I've heard of it but admittedly I don't know that much about Bitcoin.

See the link below. It includes a stack based scripting language (essentially a subset of Forth) for processing transactions so you can do some customization in how transactions unfold. As I understand it (and I don't know much about Ethereum) a big difference is that Eth has a Turing complete scripting language that can run code as part of transaction, while bitcoin only has a subset that doesn't include e.g. looping.

https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Script

Ah this is neat. I was definitely not aware of this. Thanks for the link.
Wow, exactly how I feel. Never seen this take put so eloquently before. Kudos, mate.