[jtimberman]

1. Yeah, the stop-gap "solution" is to white list a number of attributes in order to reduce the data set, because in the most common use case we see, there's only a few attributes that people actually care about in the chef-client context. The node's run list, its IP address or FQDN. Really. That is the most common. For like, 90%+ of the use cases out there. Everyone has a unique snowflake and thats cool, but really, not that much.

2. There's no assumption that systems are correctly configured other than they start from a baseline configuration in the most common use case. We have worked with several customers managing existing infrastructures of running systems that had an unknown baseline and Chef was able to automated the pieces they cared about.

Again with "most common use case."