Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Meai 1501 days ago
Doesn't Apple forbid publishing web apps on the app store? How is it then possible that something like ionic framework and react native still work? Unless they literally translate all html features to native components but I seriously doubt it.

Edit: This is a "talk to sales" framework and ionic is 50€ per month as the absolute cheapest option. This is essentially an ad then.
2 comments
systoll 1501 days ago
> Unless they literally translate all html features to native components but I seriously doubt it.

React Native doesn’t use HTML. It has its own set of base tags (eg 'Text', 'Image', 'ScrollView') that are then translated to native components.

(Though, to complicate matters further, 'React Native for Web' exists, and translates those into HTML tags https://necolas.github.io/react-native-web/docs/ )

link
jbverschoor 1501 days ago
Nice.. I didn't know about that!
link
vore 1501 days ago
I'm pretty sure Apple is OK with web apps: https://ionic.io/resources/case-studies/sworkit

Also Ionic is definitely free and open source: https://ionicframework.com/framework

link
peterburkimsher 1501 days ago
Wasn't the original plan for the iPhone 2G (pre-app store, iPhone OS 1) to use web apps for everything?

https://9to5mac.com/2021/06/03/remembering-apples-sweet-solu...

link
masklinn 1501 days ago
Yes. That turned out to be nowhere near possible, especially for things like games. Hence the appstore.
link
skinnymuch 1501 days ago
Was it just games? WebOS’s apps were as good as any other platforms apps and were PWAs unless I’m mistaken.
link
masklinn 1501 days ago
> Was it just games?

It wasn't only games, but having been there the cambrian explosion following the appstore's release was very much 95% games (much to Jobs' dismay).

> WebOS’s apps were as good as any other platforms apps and were PWAs unless I’m mistaken.

They were built out of "web technologies" (HTML and javascript) but they were not PWAs as they were significantly augmented with native components and concepts, none of which were part of the browser (even as proprietary extensions). That's like calling Firefox a PWA because it's built out of XML and Javascript (or was, not sure that's still the case).

iOS' first draft (pre appstore) was pretty much just web pages you pinned to your springboard (which you can still do). There were a few allowances for removing browser chrome and the like, or providing a few icons, but for the most part it was exactly what you'd run in a browser.

link