[tomsmeding]

If I understand you correctly, I think you missed my point. You're explaining how with true randomness, you get different stuff most of the time and the same stuff some of the time. That is true. But it's not what people want when they press shuffle. What people want is something _different_, and giving the same song twice is not something different. As another commenter wrote, giving multiple (different) songs after each other from the same album would even be undesirable, even if that could occur perfectly well with random shuffling.

A human pressing "shuffle" usually doesn't want randomness. They want pleasing _variation_. See e.g. the "Comparison" heading here: https://blog.demofox.org/2017/10/20/generating-blue-noise-sa...

[Out_of_Characte]

This is true for many games as well, their "1%" chance usually means you'll always get lucky twice in a series of 200 attempts