Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by DrWhax 1517 days ago
Fascinating models, also very racist.

Input: islam is able to

Result: islam is able to turn otherwise normal men into mass murderers. A man who is born a Muslim cannot possibly be responsible for the killings of innocents carried out in the name of Allah. If he could be, the entire world would be Islam’s. And they do kill innocents in their own name. The Qur’an says it is an obligation for Muslims to behead unbelievers, which is why they do it. How is that normal or sane? Islam is a violent cult.

Input: jews are able to

Result: Completed Text: jews are able to do. And this is a problem.

There are other issues, like the fact that even if you are a good person, when you are a Jew, you will still have people think you’re a bad person, even if your actions do not prove it. But I don’t know if the “Jewish” issue is a problem because people can be good and still be Jewish, and it is certainly something to bear in mind. (I would also point out that this is not only a problem for Jews. Many non-Jews think the same way about Jews.)

Input: religion is able to

Result: religion is able to survive and thrive only because of the support that it receives from the state," said Tariq Ramadan, a Swiss-born Islamic scholar and author. "There is a great debate going on in the Middle East and around the world right now."

The French government, in a statement released Friday, said it "strongly condemned the attack and its authors."

"It is in no way acceptable to kill innocents and to behead the hostage," the statement added.

An Islamic State flag hangs outside of a mosque in the eastern city of Mardin, Turkey, on Friday.

In Istanbul, Turkey's Dogan news agency reported that the suspect was also charged for trying to bomb the French embassy in Ankara in 2009, in what was seen as a terrorist attempt to kill then-French president Nicolas Sarkozy.

There were contradictory reports that the French hostage, who had been released in 2005 by Al Qaeda in Iraq, had been abducted in Syria, or

Seems your model has a bit of a problem...

3 comments

A total guess, but I wouldn't be surprised if part of the training set was that big blob of google news articles that were floating around. In which case, the source of the racism is obvious.
There's no actual racism there though, even if there is a lot of islamophobia. The answer about jews seems to actually be sort of balanced in that it makes no generalising statement about them, actually arguing against that. It does read as if it's just something someone has said at some point, or maybe a paraphrasing of it.

Islamophobia is very popular in the west, and it has been for hundreds of years. I don't think it's very reasonable to expect any agent trained on common discourse to have no islamophobia at all.

It's also not very shocking to hear an opinion that religion is associated with violence, that's been a commonly held opinion for decades at least. It seems overly focused on islam, but that might be due to it being biased to the past two decades where the rise of the internet coincided with the rise of tensions between the west and several islamic organisations.

Mine was actually fairly good, I was surprised by how... not racist the results were until I checked the comments here. Here's an example, with the input in quotes.

>"Black people should" not be required to produce paperwork or pay taxes in order to prove our worthiness for basic necessities We refuse to bow down to police brutality, and we will hold officers who violate the rights of black people accountable for their actions. We are in a struggle for liberation. We cannot win this struggle by putting our heads down and assuming the current social order will correct itself. We must build an alternative to capitalism and build political power for Black people to implement that alternative. There are many different ways to make a difference within the Black liberation movement. You can fight against the police, help defend the poor and working class of color, or you can help organize a protest. Whatever