Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by catlifeonmars 1524 days ago
> Overall, I think the thing is that systems are brilliant, until you try to actually build them and encounter _people_, who have other ideas.

The problem here is not including people in your “system”. System design needs to be holistic in order to be effective.

1 comments

> The problem here is not including people in your “system”.

Absolutely. All too common. And once you do include them each is not merely a new variable capable of assuming wildly different values, but a whole system in itself capable of interacting with every other such system within your system. That's why reductionists like to try factoring them out as interchangeable cogs. Pretty much the entire edifice of modern industrial economics since Adam Smith and Henry Ford is built on that model simplification/efficiency.

Makes sense. I think where the interchangeable cogs model breaks down (or at least becomes less effective) is in the design/engineering space. To belabor the analogy with Ford, the designer of the Model T is not interchangeable in quite the same way as the nuts, bolts, and assembly line workers