Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kube-system 1520 days ago
> And to talk about FOSS as happening in dorm rooms is 90s level FUD.

It was an example of polar opposite use cases, I certainly was not meaning to convey that all users belonged to one group of the other.

1 comments

It's also simply not representative of what's being discussed. Support for FOSS is a many billion dollar industry, and describing it as happening in dorm rooms is absurd.
I understand that. The statement was intentionally an example of an outlier, not making a generalization as you accuse.

There is, in fact, at least one person in a dorm room writing FOSS. (I've been one, myself) And there's at least one person in an accounting office who does not write software. These are examples of two individual people who have different needs. This is not a generalization of any industry as a whole.

Bringing up examples and then hiding behind 'well I didn't mean for them to be illustrative' is pretty lame.
I didn't ever mean anything else.

> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

You haven't given a stronger plausible interpretation than spreading FUD. Your only defense so far is that it was a non-representative fact bordering on a non-sequitur.