[hoistbypetard]

These weren't un-executed ideas, though. I think it lines up very well with my general sense that the best way to get to a really good implementation of something is to publish one that's lacking in some way that annoys people. Then you have an idea plus something people can contribute work to improve.

[anderspitman]

> These weren't un-executed ideas, though

I think you're straw-manning what I said a bit.

[hoistbypetard]

Not intentionally… I am arguing that “Almost seems to challenge the common assertion that execution is more important than a great idea” is not the case. Because these ideas were executed.