| Fair. I was coarse. Reading through, I was able to see it Life, people, come with a bazillion, edge, corner, intersection cases, right? I am moved by the likes of Lessig, RMS, others in that we are super complex! And computer tech right now is missing a couple big things! Meaning and reasoning basically. Context is hard. In the "we just want to play on a fair field" context, of course! I get it. Tech can help with cheaters for sure, though I do think it is a temporary help at best. The really brilliant people with resolve get through and may well be as great of a gamer as they are cheater. The challenge, "real game" is what really gets them going. One could say the same of a cartel leader, thief, and others who play this game of life in that way. And we struggle with tech and law constantly! There are parallels. Poor law causes a lot of grief, wasted time, people enduring punishment that should not, and we have a process for that. And it is a shitty process! I would feel a lot better with a similar dynamic applied where we do reach for tech tools. Another parallel: mandatory sentencing. We put people, many of whom are elected, others selected, who we believe worthy of judgement (And I know how debatable that all is, just roll with it for sake of discussion please!), into a position of real power, and we accept that because our lives are generally better for having done it. Mandatory Sentencing is a mess. Now we basically take this complex human capable of judgement and boil it down to a more rule based thing not so unlike what computers would do. I am not sure that ever made sense. Whether it does is an interesting discussion, but what I really want to say here is more about where tech falls short and put some meat behind "social", as I should have done. We are perhaps not so far apart on this. Seems my lazy comment got me a robust discussion I find far more worthy than the comment was! Nice when that happens. Circling back then, if I am to say anything, it is process which bothers me the most. When we are really impacting people, ruining lives or changing them seriously, or improving them frankly, there are no do overs. Our time here is our time and taking that very, very seriously seems like it should matter a whole lot more than it often does with tech and social / society. We are trending toward more bad fits than good in my view. RMS, character that he is, absolutely does take it hard to an extreme. He should not have ruling power, but we need that voice, just as we need ours. In that context, your push back was solid and for me useful and productive! I am better for having worked at this a bit. And these matters are important. Increasingly so. I hope my attempt to clarify and back away from the worst of my thoughts here is similar for you. We both are likely to come away from this tuned up a bit and better at the topic at the very least. (True for me) Cheers and game on! |