Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by throwaway81523 1525 days ago
Erasure codes with lots of redundant drives is how online.net's C14 storage product works, but it is much more hassle than ordinary replication, since retrieval requires reading data from a lot of different drives to reassemble the shares, and similarly for splitting storage requests into shares and recording them. C14 is a Glacier-like product where you request a retrieval and your data is restore as an S3 object sometime (up to hours) later. That makes it easier, I expect.

I agree that this would be good as a last-ditch backup for stuff like Hetzner cloud snapshots, but the primary storage for those snapshots probably has to be ordinary RAID.

Fwiw I have a bunch of data in Hetzner Storagebox and have gotten several notices in the past few months that Storagebox would be temporarily offline for maintenance, which I assume meant raid rebuilds and/or drive swaps. The most recent of these was an "urgent" maintenance with less notice time than usual. It hasn't caused me any inconvenience, but I wonder if they have suffered a spate of drive failures recently.