[ravenstine]

Maybe that's the contributing factor, but I really think it's more of an economic decision.

There are far more JavaScript developers out there, so it's easier to hire people to work on an Electron app and have crossover between other teams working on web-based projects. Write-once-runs-anywhere is also a part of it. JavaScript is also extremely forgiving and has possibly the easiest debugging experience of any language I'm aware of.

This isn't to say that JavaScript developers don't often do things that completely subvert the advantages of writing web-based apps, but those advantages are nevertheless on the table regardless. Writing a truly native application will always be more challenging than writing a web app (or even something like a Python-based app) and will always require some amount of specialization no matter what anyone says (as has been observed with React Native and I'm guessing that will inevitably happen with Flutter).

UI is also one of the hardest things to do right when writing cross-platform applications. Business logic is usually quite portable, but UI introduces geometry and fundamental incompatibilities between widget toolkits. The web, with some exceptions, ignores native widgets, thus the problem of writing UI code mostly goes away because there's only one toolkit to work with.

[socialdemocrat]

“Extremely forgiving” is what I think is worst with JavaScript and makes debugging harder. Stuff does not blow up when it should. Good debugging requires “fail fast” IMHO, not JavaScript style “keep going until it is not humanely possible to continue with broken state”

[ravenstine]

Anything that is easy can as easily have pitfalls.

> Stuff does not blow up when it should. Good debugging requires “fail fast” IMHO, not JavaScript style “keep going until it is not humanely possible to continue with broken state”

It depends on what you value. JavaScript and the rest of web technology is good at getting something on-screen and working, more or less. Many businesses, for better or worse, don't care about software architecture and developer happiness. They want something working, and ASAP, and more features to be rolled out for all platforms. Web technology, for all its faults, is going to win every time. Even better when code is written in such a way that debugging your JavaScript doesn't end up being so much of a hunt through a stack trace with layers upon layers of framework code.

Granted, I do agree in general that "fail fast" is better, and I absolutely think that it's practical to write JavaScript code in such a way, but that's not an attractive selling point for JavaScript or Electron. That's like a PSA telling people to eat their broccoli; Electron is like telling people to eat plenty of donuts, and most people are going to eat donuts because companies of all sizes are all too happy to treat the resulting diabetes (metaphorically speaking).