[inter_netuser]

The guy who came in last in his medical class. In the worst medical school in the country.

..is somehow always better...than everyone else? Always?

Professional opinion is just that, an opinion. Opinion of potentially the worst medical student, from the worst medical school. but because they got a prescription pad, they are now smarter than anyone else in America. Got it.

Health is ultimately our own decision, and ours alone.

[ChrisRR]

The worst doctor still passed their exams, and has way more medical knowledge than the average person

I wouldn't discount design advice of a qualified engineer because of the musings of a random person, so why would I do the same for a doctor.

Too many people in this thread are just going "software developers don't know what they're talking about. I had a bad experience with software once, so no developers have a clue, they're just after money"

[inter_netuser]

Medicine drop out rates: 15-18% Engineering drop out rates: 40-50% Math drop out rates: 47%

Dumbest doctor is stupider than avg math/eng. They just tend to be less autistic on avg.

"The American Society for Engineering Education (ASEE) found that between 40% to 50% of engineering students drop out or change their majors."

"So, what is the dropout rate for medical school? In a standard, single four-year program, that would put the medical school dropout rate at between 15.7 percent and 18.4 percent, confirms the AAMC."

"In mathematics, the dropout rate is even higher with 47% (U.S. college dropouts show comparable numbers; Chen, 2013)."

It's ok to question and discount doctors. Plenty of incompetent practitioners out there, well protected by powerful lobby, trade union, massive liability umbrellas.

They even passed laws to reduce their own liability.

I'm sure they needed that because they are so excellent at their job, they are only the leading cause of accidental deaths.

[isbvhodnvemrwvn]

You have to complete a number of prerequisites to be considered, never mind accepted, into a medical school. For engineering the barrier is much much lower, hence the higher dropout rate.

[inter_netuser]

The prerequisites is a very American thing. Most of the world just does medicine as an undergrad, and physicians are just as good. The US pre-req system, as well as the control over residency spots is just supply management to ensure compensation remains high.

However, with supply management of physicians, comes responsibility to ensure reliabile supply to replenish ranks to avoid surprises, and thus all efforts are made to ensure that students can pass. You simply can't have 70% fewer graduates one year, and 170% next.

"With an admit rate of 7%, it is easy to understand why the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine is sometimes viewed from the outside as highly competitive."

"Massachusetts Institute of Technology/Acceptance rate - 7.3%"

If you have good memory, and not a total dolt, you can be a physician. Analytic ability is a tertiary concern.