Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Swizec 1541 days ago
> My left wrist has been a little 'off' for a few weeks

The other side of this is that doctors in america lean heavy towards interventionism. If you go see a doctor, they will do something. Useful or not.

An american doctor will never, for example, say “Hey maybe your chair is too low compared to your desk and you’re putting too much pressure on your wrist” or suggest a series of stretching exercises to do 3x/day for a few weeks until the discomfort goes away. The best you can expect from a doctor is “eh it’s not bad enough for surgery yet, come back in a few years. Take advil or something idk”

I remember going in for a persistent cough. After 5 minutes the doctor decided “this is post nasal drip” (my nose drains into my throat instead of making me sniffly) and prescribed some medicine to take. And I’m like … yo this problem isn’t bad enough to need fixing, I just wanted to know what’s up. Too much intervention can easily make things worse.

When you have an acute problem that’s when american healthcare shines. Chronic and minor stuff, not so much.

2 comments

> An american doctor will never, for example, say “Hey maybe your chair is too low compared to your desk and you’re putting too much pressure on your wrist” or suggest a series of stretching exercises to do 3x/day for a few weeks until the discomfort goes away.

A (good) chiropractor will do the first, and a physical therapist will do the second.

You're right about regular MDs though.

Yes, I saw a chiropractor for a while and their immediate advice was to get a better chair and a standing desk, plus some stretches, because I had "grad student syndrome".
> An american doctor will never, for example, say “Hey maybe your chair is too low compared to your desk and you’re putting too much pressure on your wrist” or suggest a series of stretching exercises to do 3x/day for a few weeks until the discomfort goes away. The best you can expect from a doctor is “eh it’s not bad enough for surgery yet, come back in a few years. Take advil or something idk”

Not my experience. I've had doctors that recommended I do stretch exercises for a certain condition I had.

The few times I've been to a doctor in America (I'm not from USA) I got excellent care. They explained the whole thing, told me about options I could take etc. I was very satisfied with the doctors.

Yes it's more expensive than it should be, but that's a different matter.