Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hulitu 1537 days ago
> Beethoven Piano Sonata #14 (“Moonlight”) is a masterpiece,

Which one ? Played by Kissin ? Or by Rubinstein ? Or by ...

1 comments

Most consider the composition to be a masterpiece.

Artists/conductors 'perform' 'interpretations' of works. Whether any interpretation is 'masterful' or 'virtuosic', etc., is up to the critical listener.

Three recordings by Horowitz may have been released ... which one is 'best'? Depends on the phase of the moon and your playback equipment!

The 'quality' of a particular performance may depend on the instrument provided to the artist. The year of recording can be very important (reflects techology used). The acoustics of the recording venue are also inherently part of the performance ... e.g. too much reverb.