Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Retric 1539 days ago
> The difference your seeing

No, it’s both a different list and slightly different weighting. VOO 510 companies https://stockanalysis.com/etf/voo/holdings/

SPY 507 companies https://stockanalysis.com/etf/spy/holdings/

As to trading volume, 10:1 is comparing every stable coin. There are far more than just 2 mutual funds loosely tracking the S&P 500.

1 comments

That data is out of date. Go directly to Vanguard's VOO page and you can see that they also hold 507 companies, just like SPY. But it doesn't even matter.

Even if the fund held 510 companies, those last three companies would each represent 0.00% of the fund's holdings. We're literally arguing over a 0.00% difference between two funds.

I also think that the difference between a comparison to total market volume and a comparison to a second competitor is immaterial to this conversation. It doesn't really affect any conclusions about anything.

In conclusion, we're so far off-topic that it may be best to call this thread quits.