Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by samcal 1538 days ago
The whole point of a union is to have a way to challenge management effectively if their work conditions are worsened in the name of "efficiency".

This comment drastically underestimates the amount of capital spent on suppressing union activity, it's not as if they're operating in a vacuum.
1 comments
AmericanChopper 1538 days ago
I thought the whole point was supposedly to raise wages through collective bargaining?
link
giantg2 1538 days ago
That's sort of what they have become. A couple generations ago, it was for working conditions.

For my coal mining grandfather, it meant safety equipment like respirators so you didn't get black lung, and that the company had to send down a meal for you if you were working a double (before that you had to rely on the next shift to give you items from their lunches, if they were willing to share).

link
AmericanChopper 1538 days ago
> For my coal mining grandfather, it meant safety equipment like respirators so you didn't get black lung

We have OSHA for that today, so I don’t think the primary purpose of a union is to file OSHA complaints…

link
giantg2 1538 days ago
If you read my comment and didn't respond out of context, you'll see that they were started for working conditions. And yes, pay is part of it too.

Who do you think lobbied to start OSHA? It was the unions.

link
AmericanChopper 1538 days ago
Crediting unions solely for pursuing the creation of federal workplace safety regulations is a bit of a revision. It was a issue of significant public interest in the late 60s, and the specific reason that OSHA ended up being created was that Nixon had made a campaign promise to address workplace safety.

But regardless of the history, it’s not longer especially relevant to the roles of unions today, and certainly adds nothing to the value unions supposedly provide to their members.

link
giantg2 1538 days ago
I didn't credit them solely. Yes workers and workers right organizations supported it. Unions were the main ones lobbying it. We all know that without lobbying things don't get done in the US (unfortunately).

The question wasn't about what unions do today. The question specifically asked what unions were for. I stand by my statement that they were formed not only for pay increases, but also for working conditions improvements.

link
samcal 1537 days ago
Wages are certainly included in the conditions of work, some would say they're among the most important!
link