Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by antli35 1544 days ago
This could be a niche search engine for advanced users, but I feel that to average users this would be a strictly worse experience because they have no interest in figuring out how to "select an algorithm." They expect to type a query and the result they want comes up at the top. The search engine should be able to infer whether the user wants results that are more recent, more interactive, more authoritative, etc. based on the query, past search behavior, and anything else that is known about the user. If that isn't happening, the search engine needs to be made "smarter."

The way it's likely seen by many tech companies is that the more decisions you have to offload to the user, the less advanced your system is. An old car with a lot of knobs and dials and levers is not more advanced than a self-driving car with a single control, select destination. Some people will still prefer the old car, but it will be a niche market.
2 comments
stingraycharles 1544 days ago
I agree, it’s the classic example of “people don’t really like choice”. When you are presented with the option of a search algo, there’s always this feeling that you chose wrong. It’s an additional thing to think about, and makes things more complicated.
link
mgkimsal 1544 days ago
it doesn't have to be an irreversible choice. clicking between 'filters' should be something that takes an instant, and is one click away.
link
mgkimsal 1544 days ago
3 big buttons at the top after search results

"You're viewing through FOOBAR lens. Click here to view results from another lens".

Doesn't have to be that complicated.

link
antli35 1544 days ago
To some extent that's already implemented in the form of the various tabs - if you want very recent results, go to the News tab or click the Tools button and select a time range. If you want academic results with citations, go to Google Scholar. If you want information from books, go to the Books tab. If you don't know/care, the main tab will mix results from all tabs.

You can add three more buttons on top of the tabs that are already there, but would their value for more advanced users be worth the extra friction/confusion for average users? And how would it scale if someone wants a fourth, fifth, or tenth "lens"?

link