[javadocmd]

You've not refuted the article so much as pointed out a corner case the author didn't address in which ML is a good fit. Your example, using ML to perform the medical coding function, is using a data source (in this case the EMR) for one of the purposes for which it was explicitly designed and for which it is (arguably) non-deficient. That is a realm not doomed to failure.

The realm doomed to failure is using a data source for a completely oblique purpose for which it is horribly distorted. Namely, the purpose of optimizing individual and public health by discovering guidelines and treatments, diagnosing illness, and delivering optimal care.

(Of course medical billing as an enterprise shouldn't even exist, but that is another topic.)

[ialyos]

Thanks for the nuance. I completely agree with how you've framed the situation.