Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by andy_ppp 1546 days ago
Bladerunner 2049 is amazing as is Arrival and Sicario.
2 comments

Bladerunner 2049 is so slow with such a bland uneventful story and I don't think that cinematography or visuals are enough to compensate for a weak story. I just found the whole thing incredibly boring.

To make a parallel between cinematography and special effects - I think at this point people are kind of dismissive of movies that emphasize special effects and there's this old George Lucas quote that "a special effect without a story is a pretty boring thing". But swap "special effect" for "cinematography/visuals" and suddenly movies like Bladerunner 2049 are treated like they are masterpieces even though they hardly have any story to tell.

> Bladerunner 2049 is so slow with such a bland uneventful story

Well, it follows a similarly slow and relatively uneventful story in the original, so that's not really a critique. That's not really the point of BladeRunner, anyway - the point is the ambience, the worldbuilding, and the philosophical questions it raises, which 2049 provides in good amount. It will never have the same cultural impact that the original had, but it is an extremely respectful sequel with incredibly beautiful cinematography.

By visuals you mean when it's teal or when it's orange?
Not everything is a space opera (Lucas' is terrific!). 2048 has strong emotions stretched over a weak story. 1984's somehow had more story, but also quite slow paced.

Some of my favorite movies almost don't have a story at all, neither sfx.

It's great. The rift between sentimentality and rationality holds the full spectrum of the human experience.
Sicario is his work?! Didn't know that, but liked it a lot.