Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by x3iv130f 1550 days ago
Americans need a better voting system.

Real change is not meant to happen in the US system, unless it is pushed forward by the handful of very powerful special interests that hold the reigns, and that is by design.

Switch from FPTP to RCV or any other and the system will fix itself.

2 comments

> Switch from FPTP to RCV or any other and the system will fix itself.

No, it won't. Any system with single member districts as the sole basis for representation in the legislature has minimal impact on the problem. If you want to fix it, you need a system that structurally promotes proportionality. That doesn't have to be a party list system; I personally prefer small (5-ish) multimember districts with STV.

(Incidentally, I find the way Instant Runoff Voting proponents have shifted to preferring the name Ranked Choice Voting for the very worst of ranked choice methods annoying.)

I would recommend Ranked Pairs.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ranked_pairs